Skip to content
MenuClose
Order the sample color kit

Gray Deck Stain Colors

, by Color Guide

A screened porch with pale gray-brown deck boards, looking out at trees

Gray deck stain comes in two kinds. A penetrating gray soaks into the wood and tints it, so you still see the grain. A solid gray forms a film on top of the boards and covers the grain the way paint does. Pick the kind first. It decides which brands you choose from and how much work the deck needs later on.

DeckStainColors is run by Woodrich, and Woodrich makes no gray stain. Its six colors run from honey gold to brown, plus a clear. Every gray product on this page comes from another brand. If you end up leaning toward a warmer tone, the brown and natural and cedar-tone guides cover those, and the rest of the shades are under deck stain colors by shade.

Penetrating gray or solid gray

Penetrating gray Solid gray
What you see A gray tint with the wood grain showing An even gray with the grain covered
Range of grays Driftwood and weathered grays Pale driftwood to deep charcoal
Knots and board-to-board color differences Still visible Covered
Matching a paint chip The wood under it changes the result The chip is close to what you get on the deck
Upkeep Clean the deck and apply more stain, with no stripping The film cracks and peels over time, and going back to a penetrating stain means stripping to bare wood

A penetrating gray suits a deck in decent shape that you want to keep looking like wood. A solid gray makes sense when the boards are mismatched or badly weathered, when you want a painted look, or when you have to match a color your HOA picked. The semi-transparent and solid guides go into each type in more depth.

Brands that make gray deck stain

These six brands all make a gray or driftwood stain.

Brand Type Gray option Who it suits
Armstrong Clark Oil-based penetrating, in transparent, semi-transparent and semi-solid Driftwood Anyone who wants a gray in an oil stain. It can go on in direct sun.
TWP Oil-based penetrating Several grays among ten colors plus a clear Readers who want a stain that is also registered with the EPA as a wood preservative, for rot and mildew resistance.
Ready Seal Oil-based semi-transparent A gray among eight colors First-time stainers who want to buy at Ace or a local hardware store and skip back-brushing. Best for people who don’t mind reapplying more often.
Defy Water-based penetrating Driftwood Gray Readers who want low odor and easy cleanup.
Cabot Every opacity, including a well-known semi-solid Driftwood Gray Shoppers buying at Lowe’s, Ace or an independent dealer.
Benjamin Moore Arborcoat Any opacity, oil or waterborne Thousands of colors, matched at the dealer Readers matching a gray to their house paint.

What a solid gray means for the deck later

A solid gray forms a film on the surface of the wood. The film cannot flex as the wood moves, so over time it cracks and peels. The USDA Forest Products Laboratory advises against using opaque stains on decks.

A solid stain also limits what you can do next. Once it is on, no penetrating stain can go over it until the film is completely removed. If you later want a gray that shows the grain, you will have to strip the deck to bare wood first.

If a solid gray is still the right call for your deck, these brands make one:

A deck left to turn gray on its own

Some people want the silver look of old wood and plan to leave the deck bare or under a clear finish. A clear without pigment gives the wood very little protection from the sun, so the deck will gray under it. A gray toner gets you the look without the damage that unprotected wood picks up as it weathers. The transparent deck stain colors guide covers toners.

A gray deck with a gray house

Avoid matching the deck to gray siding. When the two are the same color, the wall and the deck floor run together and the house looks flat. A driftwood stain works best next to warm gray siding (gray with a tan or beige cast) and on modern or coastal homes. Cool gray siding, the kind with a blue, purple or green cast, tends to look better with a warm cedar or honey deck. The guide to choosing a deck stain color for a grey house walks through both.

Do gray decks get hot?

A dark gray deck gets hotter in the sun than a pale one, because darker stains absorb more heat. Driftwood and other light grays stay noticeably cooler underfoot than charcoal. If the deck gets full afternoon sun and people walk on it barefoot, lean toward the lighter end.

How to test a gray before you buy

A swatch only shows you how the stain looks on the sample board. The same gray looks different on pine, cedar and redwood, on new wood and weathered wood, and in sun and shade. Test it on your own boards:

  1. Apply each gray you are considering to a spare board or a corner of the deck.
  2. Let the samples dry for 24 to 48 hours. Wet stain always looks darker than it will dry.
  3. Look at them in morning light, afternoon light and on an overcast day before you decide.

The guide to testing deck stain colors has more on sampling.

Test the Colors on Your Own Boards

Brush each color onto a scrap of your own decking, let it dry, and look at it in the sun before you buy a gallon. The sample kit costs less than the stain you would waste getting it wrong.

Order the sample color kit